Thanks for the input, and I do not disagree with the comments. My confusion comes from the fact that I have seen this called both ways. I guess I was looking for a clear explanation ie. a rule book that defines this situation. Our league plays under the Missouri High School rulebook, with some slight league modifications. Here is another thought, and I know this is a stretch, but give this consideration. Let's say a team is behind and desperate to maintain possession of the ball. If the interpretation on this forum is correct, then could a team pooch punt the ball back into the scrum area, meaning the "crowd" at the LOS on a punt in hopes that the ball would be batted around and hopefully recovered by the kicking team in order to regain a first down??? I know this is a stretch, but a team could nearly pull off an on side kick so to speak! In any case, the rule seems a bit cloudy to me. Funny thing is, I am in my 11th year coaching youth football, and I learn new things all of the time. Willy